The Making of Biblical Womanhood
The Making of Biblical Womanhood – Baker Publishing Group
Full title: The Making of Biblical Womanhood: How the Subjugation of Women Became Gospel Truth
Author: Beth Allison Barr
Published: 2021
Subject: Christianity, patriarchy, women’s history, religion and power.
Central argument
What many Christians believe to be God’s intended role for women is, according to Barr, largely the product of historical traditions and patriarchal social structures rather than biblical commandments.
Barr, a historian specializing in medieval Christianity, challenges the belief that women were divinely created to submit to men, remain primarily in the home, and be excluded from religious leadership.
She argues that Christianity gradually absorbed patriarchal practices from surrounding societies and eventually presented those practices as religious truth. Beth Allison Barr+1
Eight major ideas from the book
1. Patriarchy existed long before Christianity
Male dominance was already embedded in ancient civilizations, including Roman, Greek, and Jewish societies.
Barr argues that Christianity inherited these social hierarchies. Their presence in biblical accounts does not necessarily mean God prescribed them.
She distinguishes between what the Bible describes and what it commands.
2. Jesus challenged traditional gender expectations
Barr emphasizes that Jesus treated women with unusual dignity within his historical setting.
Women were among his followers, supported his ministry, learned from him, and became witnesses to his resurrection.
She argues that Jesus’ treatment of women challenges the assumption that male authority is an essential Christian principle.
3. Paul’s writings have been selectively interpreted
Some New Testament passages instruct women to remain silent or submit to their husbands.
Barr argues that these passages must be understood within the social realities of the Roman Empire.
She highlights other biblical passages acknowledging women as significant contributors to the early Christian movement, including Phoebe, Priscilla, and Junia.
Her conclusion is that Paul’s writings cannot reasonably be reduced to a universal prohibition on female leadership.
4. Medieval Christian women had more authority than we often remember
Barr examines women who exercised significant religious influence through scholarship, teaching, writing, prophecy, and spiritual leadership.
Examples include:
- Hildegard of Bingen, a theologian, composer, and religious leader.
- Margery Kempe, a medieval Christian mystic and author.
- Women who exercised authority through convents and religious communities.
Barr argues that modern Christian narratives frequently overlook these women, creating a misleading impression that women have always been excluded from spiritual authority.
5. The Protestant Reformation reinforced certain restrictions
The sixteenth-century Reformation challenged Catholic religious institutions but also transformed expectations of women.
Barr argues that Protestant reformers elevated marriage, motherhood, and domestic life as the ideal female religious vocation.
The dissolution of convents in some Protestant regions also eliminated established alternatives through which women had exercised religious independence.
6. Bible translations reflected the attitudes of their times
Barr argues that translators sometimes incorporated the gender assumptions of their societies into English biblical language.
Choices involving words such as woman, wife, man, and humanity could shape how readers understood women’s status.
Her broader point is that biblical translation is a human activity influenced by historical context.
7. The modern ideal of the submissive Christian woman is relatively recent
The nineteenth century popularized an ideal of femininity centered on domesticity, modesty, obedience, and motherhood.
Barr argues that conservative Christian movements later incorporated these expectations into religious teachings, particularly during the twentieth century.
She connects this development to complementarianism, the doctrine that men and women have equal worth but distinct God-ordained roles, often reserving leadership for men.
8. Religious patriarchy can enable abuse and exclusion
Drawing on her personal experiences in Southern Baptist circles and broader church history, Barr examines how religious teachings about submission can make it harder for women to challenge authority.
She does not argue that every traditional Christian marriage is abusive. Rather, she warns that doctrines emphasizing unquestioned male authority can help protect abusive power structures. SuperSummary+2
The historical development of biblical womanhood
- Ancient Mediterranean societiesPatriarchal family systems establish male authority as a social norm.
- Early ChristianityWomen participate in Christian communities, while some existing gender hierarchies remain.
- Medieval ChristianityWomen exercise religious influence, although institutional authority remains largely male.
- Protestant Reformation — 1500sMarriage and motherhood become increasingly central ideals for Protestant women.
- Nineteenth centuryDomesticity and female submission become defining aspects of ideal femininity in influential Western cultural movements.
- Twentieth century to presentSome conservative evangelical movements present differentiated gender roles as essential biblical teachings.
Is Barr’s argument historically accepted?
Her work draws on established historical scholarship, especially concerning women’s roles in medieval Christianity. However, her theological conclusions are contested.
| Barr’s position | Traditional complementarian response |
|---|---|
| Patriarchy reflects human social systems rather than God’s ideal. | Certain differences in male and female roles are understood as divinely established. |
| Women exercised meaningful authority throughout Christian history. | Historical examples of women leaders do not necessarily invalidate scriptural restrictions on particular church offices. |
| Paul’s restrictions were influenced by historical circumstances. | Some Pauline instructions are understood as universally applicable. |
| Modern biblical womanhood reflects historical cultural developments. | Its supporters argue that the doctrine has substantive foundations in Scripture, regardless of later cultural influences. |
Critics also challenge aspects of Barr’s interpretation of the Reformation and her treatment of biblical passages. Bible Faculty Summit+1
Five important takeaways
- Tradition is not necessarily divine instruction. A practice can survive for centuries without originating in a religious command.
- History is selective. Overlooking influential women can distort our understanding of Christianity’s development.
- Scripture and its interpretation are different things. Religious interpretations reflect the historical circumstances and assumptions of their interpreters.
- Power influences religious institutions. Social and political hierarchies can become embedded in theology.
- Equality and religious faith are not inherently incompatible. Barr argues that Christianity can support equal dignity, participation, and leadership for women.
My assessment
The book’s strongest contribution is its historical examination of how gender expectations evolved within Christian institutions. It shows why religious teachings must be examined in their historical context rather than assumed to have remained unchanged for two thousand years.
Its limitation is that historical evidence alone cannot definitively settle theological debates. Demonstrating that patriarchal traditions existed before Christianity does not, by itself, establish how every relevant biblical passage should be interpreted.
The central question Barr wants readers to ask is:
Are women being asked to obey God, or are they being asked to obey traditions established by men and subsequently presented as God’s will?
This makes The Making of Biblical Womanhood especially relevant to the broader study of how religion, culture, political power, and historical interpretation have shaped women’s status across civilizations.
