Sex, God, and the Conservative Church: Erasing Shame from Sexual Intimacy

summurize “sec, god and the convervative church”

Book Summary: Sex, God, and the Conservative Church: Erasing Shame from Sexual Intimacy

By Dr. Tina Schermer Sellers | Published 2017

Central argument: Conservative Christian teachings about sexuality have sometimes created shame, fear, and guilt rather than fostering healthy intimacy. These beliefs can continue to affect people long after they become adults, including within marriage.

The author, a licensed marriage and family therapist and certified sex therapist, examines the historical roots of these teachings and proposes ways to heal sexual shame without necessarily abandoning religious faith. Routledge+1

1. The main ideas

1. Religion can create sexual shame.

Sellers argues that some conservative Christian communities teach people to associate sexual desire with sin, impurity, or moral failure. Consequently, individuals may develop negative feelings about their bodies and sexuality.

2. Sexual shame does not necessarily disappear after marriage.

People who spend years learning to suppress sexual feelings may struggle to embrace intimacy after marriage, even when their religious tradition now permits it.

3. Christian sexual teachings have evolved historically.

The author traces the influence of early Christian theological traditions that emphasized restraint, suspicion of bodily pleasure, and sexual control. She argues that these traditions are not the only possible Christian understanding of sexuality.

4. The Hebrew biblical tradition offers alternative perspectives.

Sellers highlights more affirmative representations of the body, pleasure, desire, and intimacy in Hebrew scripture, challenging the idea that sexuality must inherently be associated with shame.

5. Women often experience particular consequences.

The book examines how religious sexual expectations can contribute to unequal experiences of sexuality, particularly when female desire is minimized or women’s purity is emphasized.

6. American consumer culture contributes to the problem.

The author criticizes both restrictive religious teachings and a consumer culture that commercializes sex, promotes unrealistic expectations, and turns bodies into objects.

7. Sexuality can be compatible with spirituality.

Sellers proposes a more positive Christian sexual ethic in which mutual respect, intimacy, bodily acceptance, and sexual pleasure can coexist with religious faith.

8. Healing requires more than changing beliefs.

The book presents a four-step therapeutic approach to addressing religious sexual shame, along with practical exercises designed to rebuild comfort, trust, and intimacy. Routledge+1

2. The psychological consequences

The book focuses on several potential effects of shame-based religious upbringing:

Psychological effectPossible consequence
Internalized shameBelieving sexual desire makes someone morally defective
Body shameDiscomfort with nudity or physical appearance
Sexual anxietyFear or guilt surrounding intimacy
Relationship difficultiesTrouble communicating desires and boundaries
Conflicting beliefsWanting intimacy while feeling that desire is wrong
Loss of autonomyDifficulty separating personal values from imposed expectations

These are potential experiences discussed by the author, not inevitable consequences of conservative religious upbringing.

3. The historical argument

One of the book’s most significant claims is that the Christian understanding of sexuality was shaped by historical interpretations rather than remaining entirely unchanged from biblical times.

Sellers draws attention to the influence of early Christian asceticism and theological traditions that frequently treated bodily pleasure with suspicion.

She contrasts this with biblical material that presents human sexuality more positively.

An important distinction: Her interpretation is one perspective within Christian historical and theological scholarship. Different Christian denominations and historians disagree about how these traditions developed and how they should be understood.

4. What does the author recommend?

Rather than asking religious individuals to reject their faith, Sellers advocates:

  • Recognizing shame-based beliefs learned during childhood.
  • Distinguishing personal spirituality from harmful religious messages.
  • Developing a healthier relationship with the body.
  • Replacing fear-based sexual expectations with mutual respect and communication.
  • Seeking informed therapeutic support when religious shame affects relationships or well-being.

5. Critical evaluation

Strengths: The book connects religious history, psychology, sexuality, and clinical practice. Its approach is particularly relevant to people who want to preserve their faith while questioning sexual teachings they have received.

Limitations: Its historical argument emphasizes sex-negative Christian traditions and may not fully reflect the diversity of Christian teachings across centuries and denominations. Moreover, it is primarily a clinical and interpretive work, not a comprehensive historical study of Christianity.

6. Five important lessons

  1. Sexual guilt can be learned through culture and upbringing rather than arising naturally.
  2. Marriage does not automatically reverse years of negative conditioning.
  3. Religious teachings about sexuality have changed throughout history.
  4. Shame and healthy moral responsibility are not the same thing.
  5. People can reconsider inherited religious beliefs while maintaining their spiritual identity.

Final takeaway

The central message of Sex, God, and the Conservative Church is that sexual shame is not necessarily a requirement of religious morality.

Sellers argues that teachings intended to promote virtue can sometimes cause psychological distress, undermine intimacy, and damage a person’s relationship with their body.

Her proposed solution is not necessarily abandoning Christianity, but reconsidering its sexual teachings through historical inquiry, psychological understanding, and a more compassionate approach to human sexuality.

A particularly interesting question raised by the book: How much of what people consider divine moral instruction actually comes from scripture, and how much comes from centuries of cultural traditions and religious interpretation?

That is arguably the book’s most important question for anyone interested in the historical development of religion.

Scroll to Top